ChinaKnowledge.de -
An Encyclopaedia on Chinese History and Literature

Yuanye 園冶

Sep 7, 2024 © Ulrich Theobald

Yuanye 園冶, sometimes wrongly written Yuanzhi 園治, is a book on garden architecture written during the late Ming period 明 (1368-1644) by Ji Cheng 計成 (1582–1642), courtesy name Wupi 無否 (Wufou), style Pidaoren 否道人 (Foudaoren) from Songling 松陵 (today's Wujiang 吳江, Jiangsu). The original title of the book was Yuanmu 園牧 "The overseer of garden [construction]", yet because the term mu was more appropriate for governance, it was suggested to the author to rename it Yuanye, literally “The moulding of gardens”, comparing landscape architecture with the production of metal or ceramic objects.

The book of 3 juan length was published in 1631. It comprehensively discusses the principles and specific techniques of constructing residential gardens and villas. It reflects the achievements of ancient Chinese garden design, summarizes the experiences in garden-making, and is an essential work for studying ancient Chinese gardens. The text consists of two parts, the first one dealing with construction and buildings, and the second one on the gardens. The latter is further divided into ten parts: Site selection (Xiangdi 相地), foundation laying (Liji 立基, i.e. the overall layout), buildings (Wuyu 屋宇), decorations (Zuangzhe 裝折), gates and windows (Menchuang 門窗), walls (Qiangyuan 墻垣), ground paving (Pudi 鋪地), arrangement of rockeries (Duoshan 掇山), selection of bizarre stones (Xuanshi 選石), and the "borrowing of scenery" (Jiejing 借景) to achieve special effects. The entire book comprises 235 illustrations.

The author emphasises that the characteristic of garden construction is to adapt to local conditions and arrange elements flexibly. Throughout the design and building process, the guiding principle of skillfully adapting to and borrowing from the environment, with precision in fitting the context should be followed. Ji Cheng therefore concludes that "even if gardens are made by man, they should appear as if naturally formed by Heaven" (sui you ren zuo, yuan zi tian kai 雖由人作,宛自天開).

The section on buildings highlights the differences between garden buildings and regular residential buildings, architectural styles, the close integration between garden structures and landscapes, the art of variation, and innovation. It also explains the names, meanings, and interpretations of various types of garden buildings. The layout of garden buildings is the first step in architectural design and must be mutually agreed upon by both the owner and the builder.

Images 1-4. Illustrations from the Yuanye 園冶
Asymmetrical roof construction (right) and basement of a pavilion(left).
Examples of lattice windows (right) and mural decoration (left).

The section on decoration discusses the decoration of garden buildings, including elements like folding or screen doors (pingmen 屏門), decorated ceilings (yangchen 仰塵), lattice windows (huge 戶槅), open-work shutters (fengchuang 風窗), balustrades (langan 欄桿), and other small woodwork. The author advocated a combination of straightness and curves and urges owners to make use of intricate complexity. The illustrations give examples of how to innovate and reject conventional patterns.

There are also some innovations in craftsmanship mentioned in the book, such as the "one-module petal technique" (yi liao dou ban 一料斗瓣), where small, standardised components are assembled into various patterns. Ji Cheng also introduces the construction techniques for white plaster walls (baifen qiang 白粉墻), polished brick walls (mozhuan qiang 磨磚墻), perforated brick walls (louzhuan qiang 漏磚墻) and rubble stone walls (luanshi qiang 亂石墻). With appropriate design, waste materials could be used to create intricate and charming designs and patterns, for instance, the use of old, broken tiles to plaster pathways.

For the creation of rockeries or artificial "mountain landscapes", the architect must closely study the characteristics of real mountains and waters to be able to "make the false appear real" (zuo jia cheng zhen 做假成真). Rocks were to be stacked according to texture or natural striations. Ji Cheng challenges the prevailing superstition around the exclusive use of "patterned stones" (huashi 花石) from Lake Taihu 太湖. Instead, he proposes to use a much more comprehensive range of materials which can contribute significantly to reducing costs and broadening available options for construction and design.

Ji Cheng's Yuanye is also remarkable for the high quality of the language, characterised by parallelisms, four-syllable phrases, ornate language, and a rich use of classical allusions.

Sources:
Bao Jifeng 鮑繼峰. 1993. "Yuanye 園冶." In Zhonghua baike yaolan 中華百科要覽, edited by Shi Quanchang 石泉長, 1102. Shenyang: Liaoning renmin chubanshe.
Cai Jun 蔡軍. 2018. "Yuanye jianzhu leixing kao 《園冶》建築類型考." Jianzhushi 建築師 2018 (2): 51-56.
Cao Xun 曹汛. 1998. "Yuanye 園冶." In Zhongguo da baike quanshu 中國大百科全書, part Meishu 美術, vol. 2, 1033. Beijing and Shanghai: Zhongguo da baike quanshu chubanshe.
Chen Hong 陳鴻. 2010. "Yi duo zheng yuan zhongbu wei li fenxi Yuanye lunshu de zaoyuan shoufa 以拙政園中部為例分析《園冶》論述的造園手法." Keji xinxi 科技信息 2010 (13): 778+785.
Chen Wangheng 陳望衡. 2013. "Yuanye de huanjing meixue sixiang 《園冶》的環境美學思想." Zhongguo yuanlin 中國園林 29 (2): 40-45.
Cheng Yukun 成玉寧. 2018. "You Yuanye dao Yuanyan: Lun Meng Zhaozhen Xiansheng Zhonghua fengjing yuanlin sixiang de chuancheng yu chuangxin 由《園冶》到《園衍》——論孟兆禎先生中華風景園林思想的傳承與創新." Zhongguo yuanlin 中國園林 34 (1): 58-61.
Chiu, Che Bing, transl. 1997. Ji Cheng, Yuanye, le traité du jardin (1634). Paris: Édition de l'Imprimeur.
Gu Mengchao 顧孟潮. 1993. "Yuanye 園冶." In Shijie baike zhuzuo cidian 世界百科著作辭典, edited by Ru Xin 汝信, 366. Beijing: Zhongguo gongren chubanshe.
Hardie, Alison, transl. 1988. Ji Cheng: Craft of Gardens. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Hu Luyao 胡露瑤, and Zheng Wenjun 鄭文俊. 2018. "Yuanye zhijing sheji lifa tanxi 《園冶》植景設計理法探析." Zhongguo yuanlin 中國園林 34 (12): 122-125.
Kuitert, Wybe. 2015. "Borrowing Scenery and the Landscape that Lends: The Final Chapter of Yuanye." Journal of Landscape Architecture 10 (2): 32–43.
Ren Lanhong 任蘭紅, Zhang Dayu 張大玉, and Ding Lei 丁磊. 2018. "Yuanye yu Changwuzhi guanyu duoshan lishui zhangjie bijiao yanjiu 《園冶》與《長物志》關於「掇山理水」章節比較研究." Zhongguo yuanlin 中國園林 34 (8): 131-135.
Wang Lumin 王魯民. 2010. "Qingjing yu lunshuo: YUanye yu Shuoyuan bidu chuyi 情境與論說——《園冶》與《說園》比讀初議." Zhongguo yuanlin 中國園林 26 (4): 11-12.
Wang Ruilong 王睿隆, Bian Qian 邊謙, and Meng Zhaozhen 孟兆禎. 2021. "Qiao yu yin jie ,jing zai ti yi: Cong Yuanye yuan dao qionghuaxian ji 巧於因借,精在體宜——從《園冶》園到「瓊華仙璣」." Zhongguo yuanlin 中國園林 37 (1): 133-138.
Wang Shaozeng 王紹增. 2012. "Lun Yuanye de rujing shi sheji, xiezuo yu jiedu fangfa 論《園冶》的「入境式」設計、寫作與解讀方法." Zhongguo yuanlin 中國園林 28 (12): 48-50.
Wang Shiren 王世仁. 1987. "Yuanye 園冶." In Zhongguo da baike quanshu 中國大百科全書, part Zhexue 哲學, vol. 2, 1129. Beijing and Shanghai: Zhongguo da baike quanshu chubanshe.
Wang Yuguang 王余光, and Xu Yan 徐雁, eds. 1999. Zhongguo dushu da cidian 中國讀書大辭典, 1204. Nanjing: Nanjing daxue chubanshe.
Xia Lisen 夏麗森. 2012. "Ji Cheng Yuanye zai Ou-Mei de chuanbo ji yingxiang 計成《園冶》在歐美的傳播及影響." Zhongguo yuanlin 中國園林 28 (12): 43-47.
Xiao Xian 肖嫻. 2019. "Keji dianji Yingyi yi wenhua yiyi: Yi Yuanye wei li 科技典籍英譯之文化迻譯——以《園冶》為例." Shanghai fanyi 上海翻譯 2019 (3): 55-60+95.
Xing Zhishan 邢志善. 1987. "Yuanye 園冶." In Wenyi meixue cidian 文藝美學辭典, edited by Wang Xiangfeng 王向峰, 663. Shenyang: Liaoning Daxue chubanshe.
Xu Qingquan 徐清泉. 1996. "Yuanye 園冶." In Zhongguo xueshu mingzhu tiyao 中國學術名著提要, vol. Meishu 藝術卷, edited by Zhou Gucheng 周谷城, 980. Shanghai: Fudan daxue chubanshe.
Yin Shuaike 陰帥可, and Du Yan 杜雁. 2012. "Yi jing qi xi yin jing cheng jing: Yuanye de jichu sheji siwei 以境啟心因境成景——《園冶》的基礎設計思維". Zhongguo yuanlin 中國園林 28 (1): 85-87.
Zhang Dapeng 張大鵬, and Zhang Wei 張薇. 2013. "Yuanye yanjiu de huigu yu zhanwang 《園冶》研究的回顧與展望." Zhongguo yuanlin 中國園林 29 (1): 70-75.
Zhang Shiqing 張十慶. 1995. "Yuanye 園冶." In Zhongguo shumu jianzhu baike cidian 中國土木建建築百科辭典, vol. Jianzhu 建築, edited by Li Guohao 李國豪, et al., 410. Beijing: Zhongguo jianzhu gongye chubanshe.
Zheng Xi 鄭曦, and Sun Xiaochun 孫曉春. 2009. "Yuanye zhong de shuijing lifa tanxi 《園冶》中的水景理法探析". Zhongguo yuanlin 中國園林 25 (11): 20-23.
Zhu Youjie 朱有玠. 1998. "Yuanye 園冶." In Zhongguo da baike quanshu 中國大百科全書, part Jianzhu Yuanlin Chengshi guihua 建筑·園林·城市規劃, 531. Beijing and Shanghai: Zhongguo da baike quanshu chubanshe.